THE FINAL FLIGHT
OF
HALIFAX LV881 ZA-V
HALIFAX LV881-ZA-V: Research Project Update
January 2015
Dr Phil Marter, Senior Lecturer in Archaeology,
The University of Winchester, Hampshire SO22 4NR
The crew of Halifax LV881-ZA-V on the night of March 30th 1944 were:
Plt Off W. T. A. Regan RAFVR Pilot
WO2 W. W. Norris RCAF Navigator
Flt Sgt N. Wilmot RAFVR Bomb Aimer
Flt Sgt A. D. Lawes RAFVR Flt Engineer
Sgt D. L. Smith RAFVR WOP/Gunner
Flt Sgt E. H. Birch RAAF Mid Upper Gunner
Sgt R. W. Tindal RAFVR Tail Gunner
Introduction
In 2014, staff from hessenARCHÄOLOGIE (Germany) met with representatives of the
University of Winchester (UK) and of Saxion University (Netherlands) with the idea of
exploring a WWII aviation crash site located just outside Hungen-Steinheim in the Hesse
region of Germany (40km north east of Frankfurt). It was hoped that a joint archaeological
approach with project participants from Germany, Netherlands and the UK might allow a
collaboration of both expertise and national interest to tackle a potentially sensitive subject.
During the process, partnerships that formed might help to build a fuller understanding of the
challenges involved with exploring and subsequently managing WWII archaeological
remains, whilst alerting a wider audience to the importance of such sites as cultural heritage
and places of memorialisation. Of particular importance was the opportunity to provide a full
account of the fate of the lost aircraft and her crew for relatives and create a commemorative
record of events to ensure their story would not be forgotten.
A local military aviation expert and staff from nearby hessenARCHÄOLOGIE had been
aware of a crash site in the woods outside Steinheim for some time. The physical remains
and their location, taken together with objects from the site, enabled it to be positively
identified as that of the missing 10 Squadron Halifax, LV881. The aircraft had gone down on
the night of March 30th/31st 1944 during the infamous Nuremberg raid. This positive
identification provided the ideal opportunity to piece together exactly what had happened to
LV881 and her crew, some 70 years after the event.
Project progress
The international team began their work by interviewing local people and discovered that the
crash had been witnessed by villagers from Steinheim back in 1944. Indeed a variety of
local people recalled helping the German authorities to clear the wreckage away
immediately after the crash during the day of the 31st of March. They also knew that three of
the seven crew survived the crash and were taken prisoner. Survivors from the crash had
been taken to Bürgermeister house in Trais-Horloff where they stayed for the following day
and night, before they were transferred by train to Dulag Luft just outside Frankfurt. They
also knew that casualties from the crash were all originally buried in the local cemeteries of
Hungen and Steinheim.
At the same time research into the official record of what had happened got underway and
plans were put in place to carry out a systematic metal detector survey of the woodland
where the crash site was located. Whilst the practicalities of the fieldwork were being dealt
with by staff from hessenARCHÄOLOGIE, contact was made with 10 Squadron Association
who formed a small group to research the crew. Work by Ann Bihan soon provided contact
with relatives of almost all the families of the LV881 crew and helped to piece together the
surviving crew member’s experiences in the years following the crash.
Once information started to filter in from the official records and from surviving crew
accounts, a clear picture of what had happened began to emerge. Most instructive were the
diary entries of flight engineer Alan Lawes who had survived the crash and recorded his time
as a POW. His information, cross referenced with the other available evidence, including a
detailed account by Bill Norris the Navigator (who also survived the crash), created a
timeline of events that we can have reasonable confidence in. A full account will be
published in due course, but it is enough to say here that around 0030 hrs on the night of the
30 of March 1944, LV881 was attacked twice by a night fighter whilst travelling at 22,000 feet
on the ‘long leg’ of the approach to Nuremberg. The attacks resulted in the aircraft being
holed in the starboard wing. Subsequently, number 3 fuel tank burst open and caught fire.
After an unsuccessful attempt to put the fire out, the captain skipper Walter Regan gave the
order to bail out and four of the crew (Ronald Tindal, Bill Norris, Norman Wilmot and Alan
Lawes) managed to escape the burning aircraft. However, sadly in the chaos, one of those,
the tail gunner Ronald Tindal, fell through his harness to his death.
The other crew remained in the aircraft until it exploded just over the hill outside the village of
Hungen-Steinheim. From the accounts so far collected it seems that the mid upper gunner
Hugh Birch was probably killed during the night fighter attack and perhaps wireless operator
Donald Smith too. The pilot, Walter Regan remained at the controls of the stricken aircraft
until the end to give his comrades the best possible chance of survival. He probably died as
the aircraft exploded. The survivors were left to stumble their way through the dark
countryside with Alan Lawes finding his way to the village of Rodheim and Bill Norris helping
the badly injured Norman Wilmot to the village of Hungen-Steinheim.
View of the wooded hill onto which Halifax LV881-ZA-V crashed on the night of March 30th 1944. This
photograph is taken in the direction of the final flight path of the aircraft, with the village of Hungen
behind us and the village of Hungen-Steinheim just to the right of the hill. The village of Rodheim is just
to the left of the hill.
Whilst the bomber stream made its way back to England, the surviving crew members of
LV881 were beginning to adjust to their new surroundings in the cold morning air of wartime
Germany. Flight Engineer Alan Lawes’ diary records that after a few days (presumably at
the local Bürgermeister’s house) they were interrogated before they were transferred by train
to Dulag Luft Oberursel just outside Frankfurt. Alan Lawes was later transferred to a POW
camp at Hydekruge. The Navigator Bill Norris accompanied the badly injured bomb aimer
Norman Wilmot to a series of military hospitals before having to leave him at Obermassfeld
(which was a military hospital attached to Stalag IX-C at Bad Sulza) and escort a party of
wounded servicemen onto Hydekruge. Alan and Bill were later part of the 'long march' made
by many ahead of the advancing red army. Alan, Bill and Norman all survived the war.
Walter Regan, Donald Smith and Hugh Birch were buried in Steinheim cemetery where their
graves were cared for by local people, before being moved to Hannover war cemetery in
1948. Tail gunner Ronald Tindal was buried in nearby Hungen cemetery but was later
transferred to Hannover with the others.
An examination of the official records available also showed that our project team were not
the first to visit the crash site. Immediately after the war, Squadron Leader J. H. Sanderson,
of MRES Section no 14 of No 3 Missing Research Enquires Unit investigated the crash site
in January 1947. He interviewed the local Bürgermeister and talked to local people, locating
and identifying the bodies of the 4 airmen killed. He did not at that time, realise that the
aircraft involved was LV881 but was able to ascertain the names of the deceased crew. He
hoped that this would allow the crashed aircraft to be identified back in England.
Fieldwork at the crash site
At the crash site in 2014, an initial season of fieldwork has successfully explored the
immediate environs and focussed specifically on an area where the cockpit/forward
compartment of the aircraft had lain. The hilltop where the wreckage had fallen is now
largely covered by trees (more so than it had during 1944) and whilst this has helped to
preserve the original resting place of objects, it has made the work of actually locating them
challenging. Metal detectors were used to identify scatters of material across the hill top in
the hope of better understanding the aircrafts final moments. The cockpit area was
investigated by creating a gridded excavation area where it had lain and then numbering and
examining each square individually. This would provide a way to recover very small objects
and provide a distribution plot of material. The majority of artefacts recovered during this
work are now being cleaned and processed at the University of Winchester. Objects include
plastic cable duct, Perspex from the windows, the remains of instrument dials, various leaver
parts, cabling, switches and lights. Perhaps among the most interesting objects found
include what appears to be a lens from the bomb sight used by Norman Wilmot (found
during excavation) and an RAAF cap badge that belonged to the mid upper air gunner Hugh
Birch, that was found during the metal detector survey. The badge is currently being
conserved in Germany by hessenARCHÄOLOGIE and will be returned in due course to his
family in Australia.
Excavation underway at Hungen-Steinheim, August 2014
This was the final resting place of the forward section of the fuselage. Items found were primarily from
the forward compartment that housed the navigation and communication equipment, together with the
bomb sight.
Postscript
Additional details of events continue to come to light from both the fieldwork and the
accompanying research. The team will also be returning to the crash site this August to
continue excavation. We hope that our work will ensure that this crew’s story will not be
forgotten and that their brave sacrifice will linger in our memories long into the future. I leave
you with the most remarkable and welcome discovery of all, that LV881’s flight engineer
Alan Lawes is still with us at the age of 91, a fact not known to any of us at the outset of the
project. I had the very great honour of meeting Alan just recently and although his health is
not what it once was he is well looked after by his two sons Mark and Peter who generously
shared their time with me. We wish Alan well and hope he approves of our project and
forgives our intrusion into his personal wartime story. He, like his crew, remain an inspiration
to all of us who are dedicated to remembering the remarkable sacrifices made by the
wartime crews of ‘Shiny Ten’.
In Remembrance of the crew of Halifax LV881 ZA-V.
The author is currently exploring the possibility of creating a memorial at the crash site and
will be helping to publish a more substantial account of the fate of LV881 and her crew in
due course. Should you wish to find out any more about this project or contribute in any way
please contact Dr Phil Marter: Phil.Marter@winchester.ac.uk.
RESEARCHERS INVOLVED IN THE PROJECT
hessenARCHÄOLOGIE, Germany
Dr Udo Recker, Director of Archaeology of the German Federal State of Hesse.
Christoph Röder, Archaeologist
Bernd Steinbring, Archaeologist
Michael Gottwald, Archaeologist
Also in Germany: Mirko Mank, Independent Aviation Expert
Saxion University, Daventer, The Netherlands
Pim Alders, Course Director of Archaeology
Ronald Visser MA, Lecturer in Archaeology
The University of Winchester, UK
Dr Phil Marter, Senior Lecturer in Archaeology
Steve Hubbard, Archaeologist
10 Squadron Association
Ann Bihan, researcher
THE HALIFAX
A Mk 2 Merlin-engined Halifax (not as LV881- which was a Mk 3) but nevertheless interesting
to show the cutaway areas of the fuselage.
The Mk 3 below, had rectangular tail fins, rounded wingtips, Bristol Hercules engines and a
less prominent tailwheel.
Mk lll Halifax
From a WW2 Rescue Manual for Ground Crew
Halifax Mk lll Markings May 1944 – May 1945
The Bomber Command Memorial
in Hyde Park, London
unveiled by
Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth ll
on 28 June 2012