AR banner
Search Tips
A A

• Kracker Archive
• Allied Losses
• Archiwum Polish
• Paradie Canadian
• RCAF
• RAAF
• RNZAF
• USA
• Paul McGuiness RAAF Archive
• Searchable Lists

Archive Report: Allied Forces

Compiled from official National Archive and Service sources, contemporary press reports, personal logbooks, diaries and correspondence, reference books, other sources, and interviews.
Check our Research databases: Database List



We seek additional information and photographs. Please contact us via the Helpdesk.
9.11.1944 No. 625 Squadron Lancaster III NG239 CF-A F/O. Allan Bruce


Operation: Wanne-Eickel

Date: November 9, 1944, day raid

Unit: No. 625 Squadron

Type: Lancaster I

Serial: NG239

Code: CF-A

Base: Kelstern

Location: Resse, 3km North of Gelsenkirchen, Germany

Pilot: F/O Allan Bruce RCAF J27531 Age 22 Killed (1)

F/E: P/O Jack Holton 183746 Age 20 Killed (2)

Nav: F/O Lindsay Leonard Guthrie RCAF J29986 Age 23 Killed (3)

Air/Bmr: F/O Edward John Brown RCAF J37886 Age 32 Killed (4)

W/Op/Air/Gnr: P/O Norman Gordon Marler RCAF J95392 Age 22 Killed (5)

Air/Gn: P/O Earl Duncan Wilmot RCAF J95499 Age 21 Killed (6)

Air/Gnr: P/O Vincent Daniel Campbell RCAF J95217 Age 21 Killed (7)



INTRODUCTION

Fresh out of OTU and 11 Base, F/O Bruce and crew arrived at RAF Kelstern on September 7, 1944—long on theory but short on practical combat experience. With the exception of the Flight Engineer, this was a Canadian crew. Average age 23.

Although they had no control over it, the timing of commencing their operational tour could not have been better. 625 Squadron had weathered almost a year of ops and had survived staggering aircrew losses from the Battle of Berlin and the lead up to and support of the D-Day invasion. In the process the Squadron would suffer six of the seven multi loss raids of three aircraft or more. The seventh to Essen on October 23/24 would have been a wake up call for them.

F/O Bruce would be introduced to the grim reality of operational flying on 16.9.44, as second ‘dickey’ with F/O Pattison RAAF and his crew, in ND863, on an uneventful bombing raid to RHEINE SALZBERGEN.

After this trip he and his crew were flung into the fray, fast and furious, participating in raids almost without a breather—mentally and physically exhausting:

1. 17.9.44 PB531 F/O Bruce and crew, ELKENHORST, uneventful trip.

2. 20.9.44 ND452 F/O Bruce and crew, CALAIS, uneventful trip.

3. 23.9.44 PB581 F/O Bruce and crew, NEUSS, uneventful trip.

4. 26.9.44 PB556 F/O Bruce and crew, CALAIS, uneventful trip.

5. 27.9.44 PB556 F/O Bruce and crew, CALAIS, uneventful trip.

6. 5.10.44 PB581 F/O Bruce and crew, SAARBRÜCKEN, uneventful trip.

7. 7.10.44 PB581 F/O Bruce and crew, EMMERICH, uneventful trip.

8. 11.10.44 PB581 F/O Bruce and crew, FREDERIK HENDRIK, abortive sortie-all bombs brought back. (…due to very bad weather and much low cloud, all the a/c were instructed by the Master Bomber to return to Base with their bombs.)

9. 14.10.44 PB581 F/O Bruce and crew, DUISBURG, uneventful trip. (Squadron losses LL956 six minutes after take off)

10. 14.10.44 PB 581 F/O Bruce and crew, DUISBURG, uneventful trip. (Same day, same aircraft!)

11. 25.10.44 PB556 F/O Bruce and crew, ESSEN, uneventful trip. (Squadron would suffer its seventh and final triple loss raid the day before, to the same target.

12. 28.10.44 PB556 F/O Bruce and crew, COLOGNE, uneventful trip.

13. 29.10.44 NG239 F/O Bruce and crew, DOMBURG. Task abandoned over target at 13.05 hrs from a height of 8,000 ft. (As instructed by Master Bomber).

14. 30.10.44 NG239 F/O Bruce and crew, COLOGNE, uneventful trip.

15. 31.10.44 NG239 F/O Bruce and crew, COLOGNE, uneventful trip.

16. 2.11.44 NG239 F/O Bruce and crew, DÜSSELDORF, F/O C.R. Parker, 2nd Pilot and crew, but with F/O Bruce’s regular Nav and Rear Gunner. Uneventful trip. (F/O Parker would tour expire)

17. 4.11.44 NG239 F/O Bruce and crew, BOCHUM, uneventful trip.

18. 6.11.44 NG239 F/O Bruce and crew, GELSENKIRCHEN, uneventful trip.

19. 9.11.44 NG239 F/O Bruce and crew, Up 08:24 Down-, WANNE-EICKEL. Failed to return—no news after takeoff.

 

ORB Summary of Events:

KELSTERN. 9.11.44 OPERATIONS. 22 aircraft were detailed to attack the target—WANNE EICKEL. Weather conditions on the outward journey were very bad, with 10/10ths cloud all the way. When over the target area, cloud was still very bad even up to 20,000 feet. Owing to this fact, accurate bombing by visual means was not possible, and all the aircraft bombed on H2S or GEE. One of our aircraft—“N” was seen over the target area losing height with its wheels down, and this aircraft was later reported missing from this Operation. Results of this attack could not be assessed. Altogether two of our aircraft failed to return from this Operation.

ng239-map_b044c273.jpg

REASON FOR LOSS AND AFTERMATH

As this was a day raid it was not included in Theo Boiten’s Nachtjagd War Diaries or the Nachtjagd Combat Archive series:

…I don't however have any Flak or day fighter claims details for either of these a/c, still working my way through new Flak records but not come across these yet.

However, the following document provides cause, time and location of this loss:

ng239-crash-details_b07bfd96.jpg

During the M.R.E.S. investigation of this loss it became apparent the significant hurdles encountered, in their efforts to locate and identify missing airmen. The following document from the NG239 loss exemplifies this:

ng239-mres-report_45c48d82.jpg

BOMBER COMMAND WAR DIARIES

9 November 1944

WANNE-EICKEL

256 Lancasters and 21 Mosquitoes of 1 and 8 Groups to attack the oil refinery. Cloud over the target was found to reach 21,000 feet and the sky markers dropped by the Oboe Mosquitoes disappeared as soon as they ignited so the Master Bomber ordered the force to bomb any built-up area. The town of Wanne-Eickel reports only 2 buildings destroyed, with 4 civilians and 6 foreigners killed. It must be assumed that other towns in the Ruhr were hit but no details are available. 2 Lancasters lost.


NACHTJAGD WAR DIARIES VOLUME TWO:

As noted above no account of this raid as it was carried out in daylight.

AIRCREW BIOGRAPHIES

Photographs: Courtesy of LAC/Ancestry unless noted otherwise

bruce-allan-rcaf-lancaster-ng239-625sqn_2a067058.jpg

1.  F/O Allan Bruce was born on August 3, 1922, son of Alfred Bruce, C.N.R. baggage shipper, and Ellen Robinson, Edmonton, Alberta.

Education: H.A. Gray, grade school; Victoria High, academic subjects and Aero Industries Technical Institute, Los Angeles, California (Correspondence Course).

Hobbies: Built gas model airplanes for a hobby.

Sports: Basketball, moderately.

Occupation: Sheet metal worker, employed by McKay and Johannson Ltd.

Air Force Duty you wish to enlist for: Ground Duties, Airframe Mechanic.

January 13, 1941.

horton-jack-rafvr-lancaster-ng239-625sqn_1ed80157.jpg

2. P/O. Jack Holton was born on 22 January 1924 at Olney, Buckinghamshire, the son of Bricklayer, Albert Frederick Holton (1896-1943) and Ethel Holton née Wooding (1897-1986). He had 3 siblings: Frederick A Holton (1922-1968), Esther Molly Holton (1925-2023) and Margaret M. Holton born 1929.

In 1939 the family lived at 27 Cowper Street, Olney at which time Jack Holton was employed as a Boot Factory Hand.

His service number, 1624091, is from batch 1610001 to 1649900 which was issued at Cardington from October 1941 to September 1942. This would indicate that he enlisted shortly after his 18th birthday on 22 January 1942.

In 1942 AC2 Jack Holton was posted to No. 4 School of Technical Training (4 SoTT) at RAF St Athan, Glamorgan, South Wales. The school, which was established in 1938, originally focused on training engine fitters, airframe fitters and flight mechanics but in 1942 the unit's role expanded to train flight engineers. Jack seems to have trained as an engine fitter or flight mechanic and in 1943 he was stationed at RAF Kelstern with the rank of Leading Aircraftman.

By July/August 1944 having trained as a Flight Engineer he was a Sergeant at a conversion unit where he joined the crew of F/O Allan Bruce with whom he was subsequently posted to 625 Squadron on 7 September 1944.

1624091 Sergeant Jack Holton was commissioned as a pilot officer on probation (emergency) on 30 August 1944 (London Gazette 12 December 1944)

Originally buried at Gelsenkirchen-Hueller Cemetery he was reinterred at Reichswald Forest British Cemetery (RAF Extn) on 12 May 1947. Grave ref: Plot 20. Row B. Grave 7.

He is commemorated on the Olney War Memorial, Buckinghamshire

Photograph: Courtesy of ‘The Names on the Olney War Memorial 1939 – 1945′ compiled by Alec Morgan. Photo kindly provided by Jack Holton's sister, Mrs Mollie Cony. 

guthrie-lindsay-leonard-rcaf-lancaster-ng239-625sqn_d73626a6.jpg

3. F/O Lindsay Leonard Guthrie was born on May 23, 1921, son of Michael George Guthrie and Lilly Norris, Winnipeg, Manitoba.

Education: Luxton School, Wpg., matric; St John’s High, matric; St John’s College, Grade XII; Business College, night school, 3 months Bookkeeping and Typing. All Wpg. Man. schools.

Special qualifications, Hobbies: A.S.M. 62nd Scout Troop, Winnipeg.

Sports: Baseball, football and rowing (occasionally).

Occupation: Bank teller.

March 12, 1942.

brown-edward-john-rcaf-lancaster-ng239-625sqn_56296055.jpg

4. F/O Edward John Brown was born on June14, 1912, son of Arthur Ernest Brown and Henrietta Johnson (deceased), Bjorkdale, Saskatchewan.

Education: Plumas, grade 8; Campbellville, grade 10.

Sports: Baseball, dancing, soccer and football.

Occupation: Farming since leaving school, Sherrit Gorden Mines, July 1941-1942, to enlist.

September 2, 1942.

marler-norman-gordon-rcaf-lancaster-ng239-625sqn_6493d15a.jpg

5. P/O Norman Gordon Marler was born on March 21,1922, son of Jessie Charles Marler and Mary Edna Gordon, Toronto, Ontario; Husband of Audrey Eldred Marler and father of Sandra Diane, December 15, 1940 and Gordon Wayne, January 4, 1942.

Education: Kimberly, Toronto, Entrance Class- Commercial; Eastern Commerce, TOR- 111 Form Commercial.

Hobbies: Reading.

Sports: Extensively, hockey; swimming- moderately.

Occupation: Truck driver, Devon Dairy Ltd.

July 16, 1942.

wilmot-earl-duncan-rcaf-lancaster-ng239-625sqn_527fa180.jpg

6. P/O Earl Duncan Wilmot was born on August 21, 1923, son of John Duncan Wilmot and Ruth Paitch, Winnipeg, Manitoba.

Education: Hugh John McDonald, general; D.M.C.I. High School, grade IX.

Sports: Hockey, soccer and basketball.

Occupation: Truck driver.

December 1, 1941.

campbell-vincent-daniel-rcaf-lancaster-ng239-625sqn_1db4719e.jpg

7. P/O Vincent Daniel Campbell was born on February 1, 1923, son of blacksmith, Daniel G. Campbell (deceased) and NOK Margaret Campbell (nee McMillan), South Porcupine, Ontario, Cochrane District.

Education: Devonshire Public School, Ottawa, On, Entrance; Ottawa Tech. H.S., Ont, 2 complete years & half of 3rd form of matric cr.

Sports: Hockey, softball, mod.

Occupation: Diamond driller.

January 21, 1942.

BURIAL DETAILS

1. F/O Allan Bruce is buried in the Reichswald Forest War Cemetery, Grave 17.G.4. His epitaph reads:

His memory
Is as dear to-day
As in the hour
He passed away

2. P/O Jack Holton is buried in the Reichswald Forest War Cemetery, Grave 20.B.7.

3. F/O Lindsay Leonard Guthrie is buried in the Reichswald Forest War Cemetery, Grave 20.B.6. His epitaph reads:

In life loved and honored,
In death remembered.
His memory a daily thought

4. F/O Edward John Brown is buried in the Reichswald Forest War Cemetery, Grave 20.B.4.

5. P/O Norman Gordon Marler is buried in the Reichswald Forest War Cemetery, Grave 20.B.14. His epitaph reads:

His memory
Is as dear today
As in the hour
He passed away

6. P/O Earl Duncan Wilmot is buried in the Reichswald Forest War Cemetery, Grave 20.B.5. His epitaph reads:

Gave his life
For his country.
In God we trust.
Ever loved by us all. Mom and Dad

7. P/O Vincent Daniel Campbell is buried in the Reichswald Forest War Cemetery, Grave 20.B.9.

DECORATION RECOMMENDATIONS:

1. F/O Allan Bruce RCAF J27531: DFC.

2. P/O Jack Holton 183746: DFC.

3. F/O Lindsay Leonard Guthrie RCAF J29986: DFC.

4. F/O Edward John Brown RCAF J37886: DFC.

5. P/O Norman Gordon Marler RCAF J95392: DFC.

6. P/O Earl Duncan Wilmot RCAF J95499: DFC.

7. P/O Vincent Daniel Campbell RCAF J95217: DFC.

AUTHOR’S NOTES

The November 9, 1944 Wanne-Eickel day raid was anomalous and demoralizing for the Squadron as a whole. Just two weeks prior it had suffered its seventh and final multi loss raid with the attack on Essen: PB531; F/O Morshead and crew, PA174; P/O Tweter and crew and LM601; S/L Hamilton and crew. The sole survivors being S/L Hamilton and the bomb aimer, F/Sgt John Maurice Grace, of 462 Squadron’s Halifax LL599, involved in their mid-air collision.

Two Squadron aircraft failed to return from the Wanne-Eickel raid, NG239 and LM731 skippered by F/L J.Mc. Wilson. Both pilots were experienced and respected. There were no survivors from either crew.

We note NG239’s crew was all of commissioned rank, as three of them were promoted posthumously, effective 8.11.44. F/Sgt Marler, Wilmot and Campbell. For F/Sgt Marler’s widow and children this would soften the blow with increased financial support through the Canadian Government’s Department of Veterans Affairs.

Both F/O Bruce and Wilson’s crews could be considered “Gen” crews, exemplary for the inexperienced ones. With the exception of the second ‘dickey’ trip with F/O Parker, F/O Bruce’s crew operated as a tightly knit combat team. No ‘spare bods’ to replace incapacitated crew members and no abortive sorties other than those ordered by the Master Bomber.

The loss of both these crews from the same raid would have been a devastating blow to Squadron morale at this phase of the war. The end was in sight but who would be next to get “the Chop”? It was unknown at the time, but before war’s end the Squadron would lose another fifteen aircraft and crew. This would include two double loss raids, March 5, 1945 (NG240 and PD375) and March 16th (NG169 and RF145).

What the crews were unaware of at the time was of the 256 Lancs participating in the Wanne-Eickel raid, only two would fail to return, LM731 and NG239—both from 625 Squadron. The odds of this happening are almost statistically impossible and to the best of our knowledge did not happen to any other Bomber Command squadron during the course of the war. So much for the old adage: lighting never strikes the same spot twice. Aircrew were a superstitious bunch and this would have been most disconcerting for them. Sobering loss rates: Raid 0.08%, Squadron 9% of those detailed and 100% of aircraft lost on this raid!

In addition, it was noted the weather was a major factor in target marking accuracy, and bombing was essentially ineffective in damaging the oil refinery. It would also play a significant role in the loss of the second Squadron aircraft, and leader for this raid—LM731, F/L Wilson and crew.

For the price paid by the Squadron this raid was a failure, leaving fourteen families grieving the deaths of their sons. JEA

REFERENCES

625 Squadron ORB
Bomber Command War Dairies
CWGC Website
LAC/Ancestry.ca: Canada, World War II Records and Service Files of War Dead, 1939-1947

Co-Authors

John Naylor
Maureen Hicks
Mike Edwards
Phil Townsend
Roy Wilcock, photo-editing and RAF Bio

Submission by Jack Albrecht in dedication to the crew and their families.


2026-11-03 RW1 | Last edit: 2026-11-11 RW1
Explore related reports: 1944 625 Sqd RAF Bomber Command Canada Lancaster Roy Wilcock
Pages of Outstanding Interest
History Airborne Forces •  Soviet Night Witches •  Bomber Command Memories •  Abbreviations •  Gardening Codenames
CWGC: Your Relative's Grave Explained •  USA Flygirls •  Axis Awards Descriptions •  'Lack Of Moral Fibre'
Concept of Colonial Discrimination  •  Unauthorised First Long Range Mustang Attack
RAAF Bomb Aimer Evades with Maquis •  SOE Heroine Nancy Wake •  Fane: Motor Racing PRU Legend
Acknowledgements
We are an Amazon Associate and receive a small commission on any sales made through our Amazon link
Sources used by us in compiling Archive Reports include: Bill Chorley - 'Bomber Command Losses Vols. 1-9, plus ongoing revisions', Dr. Theo E.W. Boiten and Mr. Roderick J. Mackenzie - 'Nightfighter War Diaries Vols. 1 and 2', Martin Middlebrook and Chris Everitt - 'Bomber Command War Diaries', Commonwealth War Graves Commission, Tom Kracker - Kracker Luftwaffe Archives, Michel Beckers, Major Fred Paradie (RCAF) and Captain François Dutil (RCAF) - Paradie Archive (on this site), Jean Schadskaje, Major Jack O'Connor USAF (Retd.), Robert Gretzyngier, Wojtek Matusiak, Waldemar Wójcik and Józef Zieliński - 'Ku Czci Połeglyçh Lotnikow 1939-1945', Andrew Mielnik: Archiwum - Polish Air Force Archive (on this site), Anna Krzystek, Tadeusz Krzystek - 'Polskie Siły Powietrzne w Wielkiej Brytanii', Franek Grabowski, Polish graves: https://niebieskaeskadra.pl/, PoW Museum Żagań, Norman L.R. Franks 'Fighter Command Losses', Stan D. Bishop, John A. Hey MBE, Gerrie Franken and Maco Cillessen - Losses of the US 8th and 9th Air Forces, Vols 1-6, Dr. Theo E.W. Boiton - Nachtjagd Combat Archives, Vols 1-13. Aircrew Remembered Databases and our own archives. We are grateful for the support and encouragement of CWGC, UK Imperial War Museum, Australian War Memorial, Australian National Archives, New Zealand National Archives, UK National Archives and Fold3 and countless dedicated friends and researchers across the world.
Click any image to enlarge it

Click to add your info via ticket on Helpdesk •Click to let us know via ticket on Helpdesk• Click to explore the entire site
  You can show you value this content by offering your dedicated research team a coffee!  

At the going down of the sun, and in the morning we will remember them. — Laurence Binyon
All site material (except as noted elsewhere) is owned or managed by Aircrew Remembered and should not be used without prior permission.
© Aircrew Remembered 2012 - 2026
Last Modified: 11 Nov 2026 11:10